Politics

Vaccine Policy Shifts Spark State and Medical Group Responses

Independent Report – The recent changes in U.S. federal vaccine policy led by Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. have sparked significant reactions among medical organizations and several states. These groups are now creating their own vaccine guidelines for the upcoming fall respiratory illness season. Their main concern is that many healthy children and pregnant women may lose access to important preventive vaccines due to the new federal stance.

Vaccine Policy Changes Create Confusion Among Providers and Patients

This development introduces a risk of confusion among healthcare providers and patients, as there could be differing vaccine recommendations coming from federal and state levels. Health experts warn that this conflicting information may complicate vaccination efforts and public understanding.

The federal vaccine advisory panel, known as the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP), has long played a central role in shaping vaccine policies. ACIP advises the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) on who should receive vaccines and the timing of those vaccinations after approval by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Many state laws depend on ACIP’s guidance to determine vaccine-related policies.

Robert F. Kennedy Jr., who has a history of questioning vaccine safety despite scientific evidence supporting vaccines, was appointed by former President Donald Trump to lead the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). Since his appointment, Kennedy has significantly altered the federal vaccine recommendation process. Last month, he dismissed all 17 members of ACIP and replaced them with his own chosen advisers, some of whom are known for anti-vaccine activism. Earlier, in May, Kennedy withdrew federal recommendations for COVID-19 vaccines for pregnant women and healthy children without consulting ACIP, claiming that there was insufficient evidence to support boosters for these groups.

Also Read : Idaho Killings: Kohberger Faces Life Sentence, Motive Unclear

In response, major U.S. medical organizations have taken action. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) and the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA) have filed lawsuits against Kennedy over the changes in COVID vaccine policy. The AAP announced it will create and promote its own evidence-based vaccine guidelines for the fall respiratory illness season, covering COVID-19, influenza, and respiratory syncytial virus (RSV).

Commitment to Evidence-Based Recommendations

Dr. Sue Kressly, president of the AAP, expressed strong opposition to the dismantling of the vaccine advisory system, stating that the organization “simply cannot and will not stay silent.” Similarly, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) is preparing its own guidelines, which will be released later this year. ACOG continues to support COVID-19 vaccination for pregnant women, a group at higher risk of severe illness and pregnancy complications from the virus.

ACOG also rejects Kennedy’s panel’s recommendation against flu vaccines containing thimerosal, a preservative with a long-debunked association to autism promoted by vaccine skeptics. The organizations are working with the Vaccine Integrity Project, a coalition of public health and infectious disease experts formed to monitor changes in vaccine policy, to ensure their guidelines are based on the latest scientific evidence.

Dr. Michael Osterholm, director of the Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy at the University of Minnesota and adviser to former President Joe Biden, explained that their goal is to provide an unbiased, authoritative review of vaccine data to support these medical societies in issuing trustworthy guidelines.

An HHS spokesperson defended Kennedy’s actions, describing the newly formed advisory panel as providing “fresh, independent scientific judgment” and assuring that ACIP “will continue to be the statutory authority guiding immunization policy” in the United States.

HHS Defends New Vaccine Advisory Panel

Meanwhile, experts warn about the complexities this situation creates. Jen Kates, a senior analyst at the Kaiser Family Foundation, noted that states have traditionally had varied health policies. However, the emergence of multiple vaccine recommendation sources at both federal and state levels may confuse parents and healthcare providers about whom to trust. She emphasized that infectious diseases do not respect state boundaries, which could undermine public health efforts.

ACIP recommendations have been integrated into hundreds of laws across the country since the committee’s founding in 1964. These laws affect health insurance coverage, vaccine access for children from low-income families, school immunization requirements, and the authority of pharmacists to administer vaccines. Rebecca Coyle, executive director of the American Immunization Registry Association, described the extent of ACIP’s influence as “mind-numbing.”

Almost 600 laws and regulations across 49 states, three U.S. territories, and Washington, D.C. reference ACIP recommendations. Some states have already taken steps to counterbalance the federal changes. Wisconsin, for example, continues to recommend COVID-19 vaccination during pregnancy and for all individuals aged six months and older, and its Medicaid program will cover the vaccine for eligible recipients.

Governors in California, Washington, and Oregon have condemned Kennedy’s dismissal of the ACIP members and expressed serious concerns about the transparency and reliability of federal vaccine guidance. These states intend to maintain vaccine recommendations consistent with leading medical organizations.

Calls for Uniform Vaccine Policies

Other states are revising their laws to include recommendations from major medical societies alongside ACIP guidance. Colorado, for instance, has amended its laws to allow vaccine policies for schoolchildren to be based on multiple expert recommendations. Massachusetts is considering legislation to empower its public health commissioner to set childhood immunization rules without relying solely on ACIP. Similarly, Maine has removed ACIP references from one of its vaccine access laws.

Dr. Osterholm shared that health insurers have indicated a preference for uniform vaccine recommendations, which could drive efforts to align guidelines among different groups. He stressed the need for collaboration while acknowledging the current challenge of having multiple competing authorities on vaccine policy.

In summary, Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s reshaping of vaccine advisory processes has prompted medical organizations and states to develop independent vaccine recommendations. While this aims to protect public health, it also risks creating confusion and inconsistency in vaccine policies across the United States.

Also Read : No More Guessing! Here’s the Secret to Keeping Your Child’s Blood Sugar in Check

desain ruangpapagencetMarie FranceMedia Mutiara NusantaraSports DailyBahis WonCity Career ServicesLi Cheng Wu XianBCC Ai piao5Dragons E-SportsKuliner NusantaragacorMelfrisTattoo Supreme IndonesiaPortal KulinerTribun Bolabandar slot maxwinSahabat NestleExplore NusantaraVedit Creative Studiogacor mudah menang terpercayaThe Mini SocialMonotonixArena GamersRekomendasi FilmTeori KonspirasiPortal HiburanZippo CollectionDupont LoverKids Care IndonesiaNgabrets GamingCasio GalleryYuk Hidup SehatNarasi KehidupanIrama JiwaZona PopulerGlowstoriaThe Socialist RegisterPixie Foreverslot gacorBlogtubersPremium Biz PostDiy Craft RecipesDizzy PTbrass house austinLink Login Alternatif ZonasixSitus Gacor Nomor 1 ResmiLIGASIX Link Login Alternatifpipemediaa7fr5 bloggeramerican party scassistive technology partnersAnimekuindobebimibroom corn johnnyschamber lains oflondonchaville blogclub de lisacolorado actioneobd toolgarage doors and partsglobal health wiregrb projecthaberedhave seat will travelimmovestinginspa kyotojohn hawkin sunratedkhaleej times jobsleegay lordmclubworldmeet muscatinemidwest garage buildersmonika pandeynet protozopersonal cloudsrippin kitten1 buy celebrex onlinerobert drawsscreemoshahid onlinest francis luck nowsustainability pioneersthe berk shire mallthe blackmore groupthorn ville churchvisit mark twain lakeGarda MediaRadio Senda 1680Rumah JualIndependent Reportslot gacorOXLIGA Game Online ResmiSultana RoyalDiyes internationalPasmarqueKudakyivABGXMoron CafeElm Sleepidngglink login alternatif idnggidnppSerbu DiskonBelanja Lebih Hemat di Alfamartidnppidngg loginLink Situs Gacor MaxwinoxligaEl Valle GritaHorror YearbookIdnplay NewsGang FlowKDUN RadioTech by AndroidALIVEfmFastCreaSitePrediksi SDY SGP MACAU HK dan Keluaran SDY HK SGPArcadia DailyTop Ten ThingsPlay Source InfoLestanze CafeDiesel SpecialistNGO CS TipCasal Del RavalIDNPPMeikartagrandal mas residenceAS Roma Forza RomaTutorials PhotoshopPolitikosGayPriderSitus TogelHongkong PoolsMondoRealityaroma masakhidangan istimewainspirasi masakinfo alam indonesiaPT. Tri Karya Cemerlangatalayahttps://institutolobo.org.br/Tatva Restaurantwan solutionfacility servicesrekomendasi balirekomendasi medanliburan pariwisatajelajah alam indonesiawisata alam indonesiacek kesehatanjlpt jakartajlpt bandungjlpt surabayajlpt medanjlpt yogyakartajlpt denpasarjlpt manadojlpt malangjlpt semarangjlpt makassarjlpt palembangjlpt bogorIkabi SurabayaIkabi MedanIkabi PalembangIkabi SemarangIkabi BatamIkabi PekanbaruIkabi BogorIkabi LampungIkabi MalangIkabi BalikpapanIkabi PontianakIkabi Banjarmasin Ikabi DenpasarIkabi JambiIkabi SurakartaIkabi ManadoIkabi JayapuraIkabi BengkuluIkabi PaluIkabi SukabumiIkabi KendariIkabi AmbonIkabi DumaiIkabi BinjaiIkabi TegalIkabi SorongIkabi BanjarbaruIkabi Pematang SiantarIkabi SingkawangIkabi ProbolinggoIkabi Tanjung PinangTribun OtomotifTribun TrenHarley Davidson X440bentuk kekecewaan rakyat indonesiaFilm reza arap harusnya hororXiaomi 17 siap bersaing dengan iphone 17Bocoran harga huawei pura 80 ultrajacquelyn chandraPriscilla Anabel Karenikatan takdir yi heon dan ji young di akhir drama bon appetite your majestyTema Modifikasi Chopper V-Styles Bergaya Alien BiomechanicKonsep Bodywork Mobil Sedan dengan Gaya Custom Airbrushliga champions duel ketat chelsea vs benficaprediksi as monaco vs manchester cityhonda adv160 2025 skutik adventuremarc marquez dikagumi bos ducatimobil double cabin makin gahar tips keren dan fungsionalaudio premium di mobil anda paket jbl untuk setiap perjalananmodifikasi thailook honda scoopy jadi makin kekinianpreorder oppo a6 pro 45 dan 5gvelg r15 ringan dan stylish enkeiDesain Lekukan Maserati Granturismomclaren w1 supercar hybridmotor biasa jadi ikonikpuan maharani dorong dpr dan pemerintah lakukan introspeksiluka modric tetap menggila di lini tengah ac milansengketa tambang nikel di halmahera timurIkabi Padang SidempuanIkabi BitungIkabi PasuruanIkabi TernateIkabi GorontaloIkabi SalatigaIkabi LhokseumaweIkabi PalopoIkabi MagelangIkabi SibolgaIkabi MataramIkabi Bekasidunia edukasisolusi ekonomidunia skincarezona life styledunia mistisalam mistiskisah mistisoxligaMosa Mandirisumber misteridunia misteriberita sejarahsejarah masa laluwarisan sejarahsejarah internasionalmisteri sejarahkulit sehatdaily skinskin care hariantren skin carerahasia glowingzona musikhidup trendiarsitek modernrambut sehatrevolusi teknologidunia mahasiswateknologi otomotifBukit Podomoro JakartaLRT City Ciracascomo hacer heladosWala Meron 24 Jammahjong waysgacor luar negerigates of olympus x1000spacemanlink situs gacorhttps://www.troquedeenergia.com/https://reconciliationaccounting.com/https://makmurdong.com/akun303smart leadershttps://noithatvnn.com/https://www.makemoneymakecents.com/sahabat sehatGaya Hidup Sehatdokter keluargaSolusi Kulit SehatRambut Sehat BerkilauRambut Indah SehatTren Hidup SehatInspirasi Lifestyleinspirasi hidup sehatZonaMusikIndonesiaDuniaMusikHitshttps://ikabiambon.org/la/https://ikabibalikpapan.org/la/https://ikabibanjarbaru.org/la/musikkitaInovasiOtomotifRevolusiOtomotifotomotifdigitalgayarumahmurahArsitekKreatifbelajarbersamapendidikanindonesiakebun indonesiatanaman indonesiakebun mandirikarya anak indonesiaide kreatifkreatif tanpa bataskreativitaskudunia kebunhttps://lightwiresystems.com/https://capcusjp-2.com/https://serojasejati.com/https://clbktoto-2.com/https://greenville-autorepair.com/TX Health Watch PAFI Kabupaten RiauABC del BienestarJosh ShearMedia970PanasMediaCapital PersonalCherry GamesCharleston Market ReportDigiturk BulgariaOrlando Nexus DailyDai Phat Thanh VietnamEntertaina O RamaKent Academy MiangoTwilight MovieSimple Machines ForumAffordable SpaceflightVilanoHeath Ledger CentralPilates PilaScarlot HarlotKpopStarz SmashingSalon Literario LibroamerSimpplermichaelmezonulebaksiuTEKNOKRAT MANDIRI INSTITUTERose Environmental LTDelnamliahKhasanah Sari Bakerywright printingMultan College of PhysiotherapySIPFiberPT Surya Biru Murni AcetyleneGaruda Karya MandiriPesantren Mahasiswa FIRDAUS MalangLazismu PekalonganPromo Or idSMA Negeri 1 KalasanWright Printingserver luar negeri gacorserver luar negeri maxwinserver thailand gampang maxwinspaceman pragmatic playscatter hitam mahjong waysmahjong ways 1 dan 2Wajib Tahu Kapan Waktu Terbaik Buat All OutBaru Nyadar Hp Xiaomi 17 Mampu Analisis Kartu BankerGa Nyangka Dapat Kesempatan Aktifkan Mode Black ScatterJangan Sembarangan Login Sportsbook Magic Wheel Live CasinoPancing Kombo Perkalian Sebaris Mahjong BlastPunya Kebiasaan Unik Saat Menggertak LawanTemukan Rahasia Pola Multi Swipe di Roulette Trinity MoonBawa Pulang Hadiah Colok Bebas SGP Pools SiangFokus Incar Posisi Kapten Tim untuk Turnamen Blackjack VegasHindari Tehnik Spam Putaran Bonanza Volcano BoostJelajahi Titik Kesenangan Maksimal Candyland BonanzaKembali Bikin Heboh Karena BonusnyaMakin Populer Sejak Major Upgrade TerbarunyaNikmati dan Rasakan Sensasi AdrenalinPromo Akbar Lucky Neko MegawaysBlood Moon Gametreasure islandspin royal genietwins wildsfire blaze dragonkode rahasia magical puppetone blackjackHawaii Bingowinzo wheels 09capsa susunbonus kingkong poolspola gachor roulette trinity populerseamen guardiansmega andar baharbmkg ingatkan siagagame penghasil cuan dengangame yang jadi incarankini ramai pemain barukini ramai pemain memilihklik iseng saat jenuhkombinasi leg yang bisamain santai tapi pastiminta tolong ke kakek zeuskini baccarat speed situs oxligakapan lagi bisa dp rumahkisah inspiratif bang andirungkad bermain crypto bang deniwajib coba rahasia sambaran petirmetode bermain bang surya berhasilcara pintar mas lukitodriver ojol di tangerang berturutformula master rivaldo penuhluar biasa pola dari sepuhBaccarat Mysteryblackjack maniartp live mahjong ways 3sicbo bonanza mobiletexas holdem pokerpola pengganda mahjonggates of olympus super scatterJP Fantastis Sweet Bonanza Dicelucky ball gemstonesuper bonanza kasi bigwinspaceman crashbaccarat showdown planetons plinkohongkong lottobosan kalah terusbanyak diburu pemain mahjonglangsung menang bigger barnlebih untung dari emaspaling ramai digunakan strategipecahan dan kemenangan tetapudah banyak yang buktiinsiapa bilang megahobi jadi ladang cuanpemain bali ini bikinsaldo gak kuat nampungsiapa sangka gaya mainhanya dalam waktu 2 jamkilas balik pemuda jambisudah hadir fitur tersembunyiupdate rincian strategi cerdaskesempatan besar sering terlewatiwaspada salah langkahbukan cuma soal keberuntungantanpa mengandalkan keberuntunganmencermati game gate bonanzabukan lagi dari cyrptoingin profit besar modal kecilbaru pemanasan princess 1000acong pemain poker asal jakartafais kedapatan jepe 58 jutapola simpel dari mastersepuh botak mengembangkan polateori shifu brian bikin4 pola terbaik anti rungkadberkat jepe di gatot 1000cara mudah mengenali polakisah dari bapak penjualrekor baru kemenangan tercepatBonanza Stampede Goldcandyland puppet paradedragon 5d reigntiger island questblack moon seamenscatter temple frenzylucky ball fiestaTikTok Wheels Adventurewilds jackpot planetonsbandito treasure spinstallion baccarat showdowncrash pokerverse viralsuper magic roulette trinityrush candyland duelbosen main dijadi sarana pencipta cuanjalan tikus nyata menujumetode sukses ala genrezeki ojol pontianak sulisdi bekasi senilaikisah haru seorang bapakmengintip aksi master agusresep turun menurun menangsang penyelamat seorang mahasiswaakun vip lagi rahasiabikin investor geleng kepalacuma modal teori norefreshpernah dibilang kebetulan kepinscatter bikin cashback meledakbanyak pemain menggunakan qrisiseng malah bikin hebohmanfaat fitur spin turbotak ada harapan lagiteka teki temuan scatterunjuk gigi berikan kemenanganbanyak yang tak tahuLucky Neko Maniagame kasino baccarat fortunescatter gates of olympusroulette mysterymahjong orientalaztec gems dicesicbo wheelscode of dragon spacemanbahar pearl bonanzadragon baccarat blazetiger poker treasurecandyland roulette royaleblackjack showdown seamenspaceman crash questrahasia di balikberhasil beli motor impianbikin pemain gentar berikutdicurigain tetangga duit darimanagagah memimpin puncak klasemen miliki tabungan masa tuarenyah dan tidak kerasyang bikin putaran lebihLive RTP Sugar Rush Deluxepola gratis sweet bonanza dicetips bermain mahjong ways 2bonus rollingan fantastiscandy bonanza landanalisa odd evenjam gachor Olympus diceBonanza Fire Fiestawild bandito legacylucky mahjong kingblack scatter rolettoto blood moonsportsbook magic ballneko stampede clashriko sepuh pemain sportbookcara menang stabil agarcontek pola master cripsdi malam chaos ini andishortcut pola jitu sederhanausai update game bingobang adi sukses kumpulkanbosan bermain bonanza akbarrahmat pemain pemula barutaktik pola jitu ini mengantarkanmenanti hasil eksekusi strategilangkah paling banyak di gunakankombinasikan dengan memantau panduansolusi terhindar dari kekalahanmemanfaatkan celah yang adabertubi tubi di hujaniberkat main saat jam kritisambil kesempatan multipler bigcukup menggunakan akun dananelayan banyuwangi berhasil menangkapsalah satu guru ini berhasilakan mengikuti tournamentbikin seluruh langganan teriakkenali ciri ciri roomlonjakkan pemain baru mahjongmenjadi putaran yang memorablemerayakan ulang tahun kepermainan happy neko providerbaccarat digitalroulette levelupmahjong ways 2sicbo whaleslive kasinogaya bermain mahjong wayssportsbook virtualBaccarat Trinity Blazepoker winzo worldroulette mega fortunemahjong puppet palaceblackjack speed spinrtp spaceman galaxy flipcandyland wild wheelsbakal jadi tambangjuga memberikan tiket nontonkini semua member kepungmengenal kategori scatterpara ahli kepada developerreza coba pindah gameternyata setelah diselidiki uangwarga pontianak bobol sistempetualangan semakin menarikcocok untuk semua kalanganpengusaha food truck bandungkeindahan putaran ciamikdulu seorang tki kinistrategi tahan banting alapahami selak beluk gameakhir bulan jadi jawabanhebohkan komunitas dengan penemuankisah pengamen di bogorjangan takut memulaikombinasikan 2 strategy inibeberapa khasiat turotial membacacuma perkara salah pencetpedagang cimol di jakarta pusatpemain pemula ini suksesalex teknisi hotel mencobabermain di game baru pandemickemunculan 4 scatter hitamnyantai nongkrong di warkopvaldo sang penahluk scatter2 formula anti rungkad bang abdur membagikan pengalamanmas adi raih 201 jutapedangan asongan menangkan 84 jutaMahjong Ways 3mix parlay cmd368gates of olympus 1000sweet bonanza dicemaxwin mahjong wins 3mahjong ways 3spin turbo mahjong ways 2Bonanza Island Stormsicbo frenzytiger baccarat showlucky sportsbook rushcolok toto wonderland roletbaccarat showdown royaletexas dragon pokerberkat fitur bonus bingo maniagame baru labuby mudah jepeakhirnya angan angan bang ipuldapatkan jepe manis hinggataktik pola maniz dariwanita penari di tiara resigncapsa susun online di oxligaandri seorang pecinta kucingcuma dengan modal minimalismaster aldo berhasil meraihsepuh riki pakar petirlangsung kantongi profit superrobux gratis kepada pemainskeptis berubah jadi ambisiustahun lebih maju beginitambang nikel studi kasustanpa panduan rtp wildbikin dompet auto gendutmasih menjadi yang terkuatpeneliti tekankan pentingnya peranrenovasi rumah terus berjalanproyeksi efek memanfaatkan kesempatantanpa perlu menunggu lamawarga jambi perkirakaan masihambil jalur aman kasinobaru saja amankan mekswinRoullete VirtualOver Under SportsbookStrategi Bermain Live KasinoMahjong Ways 2RTP LiveSicbo WinsSpeed BaccaratMega Wheel RouletteWinzo Toto QuestSABA Sportsbook StrikeSpaceman CandylandPola Mahjong Fire DynastyBigWin Bandito Wild RushTiger Card Blackjackmudah dipelajari dan diterapkankapan lagi baru mencobacari sampingan lewat baccaratmengenal lebih dekat megabelum berhasil cuan bermaintanpa pelatihan khusus dan keterampilaninovasi tanpa kenal batases pisang ijo cemilandengan 2x beli fitur gratisgokil game plingko di oxligaketika semua player mengincaroxliga bukan sekedar websiterenald tembus mix parlaysaat semua meributkan pola mikelspin manual turbo billysupir angkot Di tebet suksesawalan trik membuka kuncigagal dapat insentif pekerjakehidupan menarik dari mahasiswamantan narkoboyy sukses mendapatkantaktik aman mencari tambahantogel lotto singapure kiniCandy Bonanza Wheelsstarlight princess 1000rtp tertinggi gates of Olympus dicertp bersahabat lucky neko virtualmahjong ways 3Live Dragon Tiger pola wild bandito maniaBlack Candyland Balljackpot fire blaze bonanzarolet fortune templertp tiger spin sagasic bo scatter treasurelucky neko festivalbaccarat throneberburu cuan lewat gameberhasil menang besar hinggacecep berbuah manis hasilkanhingga rejeki mengalir derasketiban rezeki ganda danakontrak baru dievent 750jutakotak penuh scatter terpancarpemulung ini berhasil temukansuper megah parade chinasurprise ujang dikagetin samadari energi kegaming pertaminagemetar hadapi ratusan jutadiskusi dengan analis gamesemakin menarik media luartanpa harus pusing pikirkan strategiberkolaborasi menjadi satu kesatuanselalu berfikir keras sepanjang harimasuk saat waktu yang tepatbegini cara cek akun vipKolaborasi Resmi iPhone 17Berbekal Teori 3 Langkah Viral dari TiktokBerhasil Raih Rekor Kemenangan TercepatFenomena Ledakan Jepe Roulette Halloween TrinityGunakan Metode Klik Putar Pindah Lalu HoldSempat Kaget Karena Dapat Jekpot BeruntunSiapa Sangka Hobi Mancing di Poker Big Bass RoyaleEvent Awal Oktober Mega WheelsBerawal Iseng Download Bonanza King StampedeJadwal Bioskop Hari IniJangan Tertipu Kelucuannya Candyland Digimon StoryKunci Kesempatan Menang Dragon Fortune MegawaysNekad Bongkar Algoritme PaylinesTrik Mudah Memaksimalkan Potensi Perkalianngerinya tips terbaru parlaymencermati game dengan benarbukan sekedar permainaningin untung besar modal kecilmenggunakan budget hemat juga bisabingung cari penghasilan tambahanmenjadi salah satu primadonaRTP Live Mahjong Villagestrategi jitu live kasinolive baccarat pragmatic LCrtp roulette turbopola mahjong wins 3scatter gates of olympusbocoran live rtp pg softBaccarat Tournamentsicbo fantasyroulette treasurelive kasino gampang menangmahjong ways 2sportsbook mix parlaymahjong mysterygame viral olympus superjurus spin gacorways game princessmomen sukses saat all intutor spin cepat di gameusai bonanza mulai meredupplinko salah satu gamedengan bermain casino baccaratlotto singapore salah satuprediksi akurat toto macauzombie party game tembak ikan