Politics

OpenSea: US Court Overturns NFT Insider Trading Conviction

Independent Report – In a major legal development, a U.S. federal appeals court has overturned what was considered the first insider trading conviction involving non-fungible tokens (NFTs) linked to OpenSea. The decision marks a significant moment in the legal treatment of digital assets and their connection to traditional financial crimes.

Case Involved Former OpenSea Manager Nathaniel Chastain

The ruling was delivered on Thursday by the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan. It involved Nathaniel Chastain, a former product manager at OpenSea, which is the world’s largest marketplace for NFTs. Chastain had been convicted in May 2023 of wire fraud and money laundering, receiving a three-month prison sentence. The appellate court, in a divided 2-1 decision, found that the instructions given to the jury during the trial were flawed and could have misled them into convicting Chastain for conduct at OpenSea that was unethical, but not criminal under the law.

According to court documents, Chastain had used confidential information about which NFTs would be featured on OpenSea’s homepage. He allegedly purchased these NFTs before they were highlighted, then sold them at a profit once their visibility caused a price increase. Prosecutors stated that he made around $57,000 from buying and selling 15 NFTs, using anonymous accounts to conduct these transactions and later transferring the proceeds to his personal account.

Also Read : Airspace Safety: Investigation into Army Helicopter Altitude Errors

The charges were brought in June 2022, during a time when the NFT market had grown rapidly to an estimated $40 billion a year. Prosecutors labeled the case as the first insider trading case involving digital assets, seeking to apply traditional fraud laws to the emerging world of blockchain-based tokens.

Appeals Court Identifies Legal Errors in Original Trial

However, the appeals court found significant legal errors in how the original trial was conducted. Circuit Judge Steven Menashi, writing for the majority, noted that the jury had been improperly instructed. Specifically, the judge at trial had told jurors that a conviction for wire fraud did not require proof that the information Chastain used had commercial value to OpenSea. This lowered the threshold for what could be considered criminal behavior.

Judge Menashi also criticized the trial court for telling jurors that they could find Chastain guilty if they believed he had violated “traditional notions of fundamental honesty and fair play.” Menashi wrote that such a broad standard could turn nearly any deceptive act into a crime, which was not the intent of wire fraud statutes. He emphasized that criminal convictions must be based on clear legal standards, not on subjective interpretations of ethical conduct.

In contrast, Circuit Judge Jose Cabranes dissented from the ruling. He argued that the conviction should be upheld and that Chastain’s actions met the legal requirements for fraud.

Next Steps Remain Unclear After Reversal

The appeals court has now returned the case to U.S. District Judge Jesse Furman in Manhattan for further proceedings. It remains unclear whether federal prosecutors will attempt to retry the case based on the appellate court’s decision. A spokesperson for U.S. Attorney Jay Clayton’s office, which oversaw the original prosecution, declined to comment.

Chastain’s legal team expressed satisfaction with the outcome. His attorneys, Alexandra Shapiro and David Miller, issued statements calling the initial conviction a miscarriage of justice. They argued that the case set a dangerous precedent by criminalizing behavior that was not clearly defined as illegal.

NFTs, or non-fungible tokens, are unique digital items that represent ownership of content such as images, videos, and text, all recorded on a blockchain. The ruling in Chastain’s case could have long-term implications for how laws are applied to blockchain-based technologies. Particularly as regulators and courts grapple with how to define and enforce fairness in the digital asset space.

The decision underscores the challenges of applying existing legal frameworks to new and evolving technologies. While unethical behavior in digital markets remains a concern. This case highlights the importance of clear legal definitions when pursuing criminal charges.

Also Read : Exciting News! T.O.P of Big Bang Rumored to Launch Solo Project Soon

desain ruangpapagencetMarie FranceMedia Mutiara NusantaraSports DailyBahis WonCity Career ServicesLi Cheng Wu XianBCC Ai piao5Dragons E-SportsKuliner Nusantarasolo leveling season 2 sub indogacorone punch man season 3 sub indoKAIJU NO. 8 THE GAMEMelfrisTattoo Supreme IndonesiaPortal KulinerTribun Bolabandar maxwinSahabat NestleExplore NusantaraVedit Creative Studiogacor mudah menang terpercayaThe Mini SocialMonotonixArena Gamerskingligakingligakingligabetslot88Rekomendasi FilmTeori KonspirasiPortal HiburanZippo Collectiontondemo skill s2 sub indodr stone season 4 sub indoDupont LoverKids Care IndonesiaNgabrets GamingCasio GalleryYuk Hidup SehatNarasi KehidupanIrama JiwaZona PopulerGlowstoriaThe Socialist RegisterPixie ForevergacorBlogtubersPremium Biz PostDiy Craft RecipesDizzy PTbrass house austinLink Login Alternatif ZonasixSitus Gacor Nomor 1 ResmiLIGASIX Link Login Alternatifpipemediaa7fr5 bloggeramerican party scassistive technology partnersanoboybebimibroom corn johnnyschamber lains oflondonchaville blogclub de lisacolorado actioneobd toolgarage doors and partsglobal health wiregrb projecthaberedhave seat will travelimmovestinginspa kyotojohn hawkin sunratedkhaleej times jobsleegay lordmclubworldmeet muscatinemidwest garage buildersmonika pandeynet protozopersonal cloudsrippin kitten1 buy celebrex onlinerobert drawsscreemoshahid onlinest francis luck nowsustainability pioneersthe berk shire mallthe blackmore groupthorn ville churchvisit mark twain lakeGarda MediaRadio Senda 1680Rumah JualIndependent ReportgacorOXLIGA Game Online ResmiDaftar Pilihan Situs GacorSultana RoyalDiyes internationalPasmarqueKudakyivABGXMoron CafeElm Sleepidngglink login alternatif idnggidnppRadar PuncakSuper DenoxSerbu DiskonBelanja Lebih Hemat di Alfamartidnppidngg loginLink Situs Gacor MaxwinoxligaEl Valle GritaHorror YearbookIdnplay NewsGang FlowKDUN RadioTech by AndroidALIVEfmFastCreaSitePrediksi SDY SGP MACAU HK dan Keluaran SDY HK SGPArcadia DailyTop Ten ThingsPlay Source InfoLestanze CafeDiesel SpecialistNGO CS TipCasal Del RavalIDNPPMeikartagrandal mas residenceAS Roma Forza RomaTutorials PhotoshopPolitikosGayPriderSitus TogelHongkong PoolsMondoRealityaroma masakhidangan istimewainspirasi masakinfo alam indonesiaPT. Tri Karya Cemerlangatalayahttps://institutolobo.org.br/wan solutionfacility servicesrekomendasi balirekomendasi medanliburan pariwisatajelajah alam indonesiawisata alam indonesiacek kesehatanjlpt jakartajlpt bandungjlpt surabayajlpt medanjlpt yogyakartajlpt denpasarjlpt manado jlpt malangjlpt semarangjlpt makassarjlpt palembangjlpt bogorIkabi SurabayaIkabi MedanIkabi PalembangIkabi SemarangIkabi BatamIkabi PekanbaruIkabi BogorIkabi LampungIkabi MalangIkabi BalikpapanIkabi PontianakIkabi BanjarmasinIkabi DenpasarIkabi JambiIkabi SurakartaIkabi ManadoIkabi JayapuraIkabi BengkuluIkabi PaluIkabi SukabumiIkabi KendariIkabi AmbonIkabi DumaiIkabi BinjaiIkabi TegalIkabi SorongIkabi BanjarbaruIkabi Pematang SiantarIkabi SingkawangIkabi ProbolinggoIkabi Tanjung PinangTribun OtomotifTribun TrenHarley Davidson X440bentuk kekecewaan rakyat indonesiaXiaomi 17 siap bersaing dengan iphone 17apakah saham pipa layak dibeli pasca akuisisi morris capitalmedia sosial detox menjelang hari kesehatan mental duniatesla pi phone elon musk jadi pesaing iphone apple waspadacalvin verdonk absen dalam laga timnas indonesia vs arab saudicitilink resmi jadi anggota iata menuju maskapai kelas duniaaston martin vantage 2025 v8 twin turbo 656 hptips cat motor jadi warna bunglon dan cara urus izinnyamemilih kamera dashboard mobil dari resolusi hingga fitursebelum ubah kabel mobil ketahui dulu risiko dan tips amancampuran etanol bbm pertamina sesuai standarIkabi Padang SidempuanIkabi BitungIkabi PasuruanIkabi TernateIkabi GorontaloIkabi SalatigaIkabi LhokseumaweIkabi PalopoIkabi MagelangIkabi SibolgaIkabi MataramIkabi Bekasidunia edukasisolusi ekonomidunia skincarezona life styledunia mistisalam mistiskisah mistisoxligaMosa Mandirisumber misteridunia misteriberita sejarahsejarah masa laluwarisan sejarahsejarah internasionalmisteri sejarahkulit sehatdaily skinskin care hariantren skin carerahasia glowingzona musikhidup trendiarsitek modernrambut sehatrevolusi teknologidunia mahasiswateknologi otomotifBukit Podomoro JakartaLRT City Ciracascomo hacer heladosWala Meron 24 Jammahjong waysgacor luar negerigates of olympus x1000spacemanlink situs gacorhttps://www.troquedeenergia.com/https://reconciliationaccounting.com/https://makmurnew.com/akun303smart leadershttps://noithatvnn.com/https://www.makemoneymakecents.com/sahabat sehatGaya Hidup Sehatdokter keluargaSolusi Kulit SehatRambut Sehat BerkilauRambut Indah SehatTren Hidup SehatInspirasi Lifestyleinspirasi hidup sehatZonaMusikIndonesiaDuniaMusikHitshttps://ikabiambon.org/la/https://ikabibalikpapan.org/la/https://ikabibanjarbaru.org/la/musikkitaInovasiOtomotifRevolusiOtomotifotomotifdigitalgayarumahmurahArsitekKreatifbelajarbersamapendidikanindonesiakebun indonesiatanaman indonesiakebun mandirikarya anak indonesiaide kreatifkreatif tanpa bataskreativitaskudunia kebunhttps://lightwiresystems.com/https://capcusmewah.com/https://serojaabadi.com/https://clbkmewah.com/https://greenville-autorepair.com/TX Health WatchPAFI Kabupaten RiauABC del BienestarJosh ShearMedia970PanasMediaCapital PersonalCherry GamesCharleston Market ReportDigiturk BulgariaOrlando Nexus Daily Dai Phat Thanh VietnamEntertaina O RamaKent Academy MiangoTwilight MovieSimple Machines ForumAffordable SpaceflightVilanoHeath Ledger CentralPilates PilaScarlot HarlotKpopStarz SmashingSalon Literario LibroamerSimpplermichaelmezonulebaksiuTEKNOKRAT MANDIRI INSTITUTERose Environmental LTDelnamliahKhasanah Sari Bakerywright printingMultan College of PhysiotherapySIPFiberPT Surya Biru Murni AcetyleneGaruda Karya MandiriPesantren Mahasiswa FIRDAUS MalangLazismu PekalonganPromo Or idSMA Negeri 1 KalasanWright Printingserver luar negeri gacorserver luar negeri maxwinserver thailand gampang maxwinspaceman pragmatic playscatter hitam mahjong waysmahjong ways 1 dan 2kurir di palem mendadak suksesoxliga sportbook jadi sorotanandika pekerja freelance di batambosan menjadi karyawan swastajaenal kurir makanan nyepinpedangan cilung di jakarta utaralangkah pertama harus di ketahuieksklusif pola rahasia yang terbongkarmahasiswa di tangerang menangpedagang minuman boba berjualanpenjual cilok kentang di alam sutrapenuh perjalanan yang tidak singkat2 masalah menangulangi pola yang rumitcoba kombinasi ganjil dan besar kecilhasil maximal yang tidak di dugaminat dengan hasil besar pedagang satehoki besar yang di alami pemuda asal jakartabukan pepeasan kosong lagi dengan modal 120 ribueditor kawakan asal depok akhirnya berhasiltanpa ragu dan selalu pecaya diri bawakan hasil maximalsudah bukan lagi rahasia manfaatkan kecedasan aimenggunakan kesabaran dan perhatikan pola di baccaratcara menang melawan tsunade ciri khas legenda saninanalisa dan memperhatikan alur jalurnyasuper populer berkat manfaatkan media sosialmahjong ways 2rtp candy delightsMahjong Wins Black ScatterJackpot Sensasional di Starlight Princess 1000tips menang baccarat olympusmahjong ways 4Mahjong Wins 3Dragon Tiger Royalemahjong wins 3gates of olympus 1000free spin lucky neko virtualmode spin turbo game pg softJackpot Olympus Black Scatterpola Ajaib mahjong wayspemain lama comeback setelahtrik pola tektok di baccaratdanni bosan bermain dota2panji memasak bebek tepungpedagang kopi starling meningkatkanterapis tempat pijat tradisionalpermainan capsa susun paling gampanggame seru menggali emaskeseruan taruhan team esportoxliga situs trend masa kinitutor mengatur bet agar bisasistem fairplay live kasinomahjong ways 2menang maxwin mahjong wild 2Secret of Olympusroulette manialive bakaratSicbo RoyaleScatter Manialucky twins carnivalmega fire baccarat bandito wheels legendwild genie adventuresNeko Planetons Spinplinko treasure empirecara sistematis menumbangkan scattercocok jadi pendamping strategikhusus pemain baru agarkunci sukses raih objektifpemain harus menyelesaikan misimencapai puncak mimpi besarsering diremehkan karena penghasilansiapkan saldo awal bulanteknik gila pakai kalkulatoruntuk cari keberuntungan dipendapatan ojek online naik pesathati jadi tenang ketikajangan takut salah langkahdebut sempurna pak rifkicontoh petunjuk menarik dalamtahapan pertama yang harustips jitu memilih gamePernah Menjadi Top Global Speed BaccaratBongkar Rahasia Cuan Harian Roulette Trinity BlazeDikasih Kode Alam Lewat MimpiIseng Ikut Turnamen Lokal Poker Fiesta FrenzyJangan Lewatkan Momen Langka IniSekuel Baru Peaky BlindersSeniman Asal Lombok Sukses Pecahkan AlgoritmeTeori Unik Tentang Tabel Paito WarnaAwas Salah Pilih Mode Putaran GratisCuman Chipset Canggih iPhone17 yang SanggupHampir Berhasil Gantikan Posisi Juara BertahanKembali Bangkit ke Puncak Klasemen Olympus ThroneSering Nge-Freeze atau FPS DropSiapa Bilang Modal Hp Jadul Ga Bisa MaxwinKasino Ultimate BaccaratKomunitas Mahjong PG Softmahjong waysgates of olympus dicemahjong wins 3jp sensasional sweet bonanza 1000poker digitalSABA Sportsbook Prototomacau pools fortunemahjong king dynastytrik super card blackjackspaceman big bangbonanza barn fiestatopup candyland magicriset mendalam terus dilakukanstrategy tak terbataskomunitas buruh jakarta dapatipenampakan multipler sensa terlihatberikut informasi lengkap yangmengenal apa multipler gandaanalisa mendalam di providerpeluang besar untuk pemain barugame jarang di mainkangame rollet blazing dengan fiturking kong pools kini mencari incaranruben mekanik bengkel suksessupir angkot sukses raihtips efektif mengelola keuanganusai mengunakan trik spin turboanalis peluang suhu brianbocoran angka togel di totomacaucasino baccarat oxliga menentukanmantan admin ini beberkan trikmengulik trik bermain casino baccaratpeluang besar untuk pemain baruDragon Tiger Palaceblack moon sicboscatter stampede sevenslucky neko crashwild bandito frenzyfire blaze roulette maniabaccarat indonesia speedPola Plinko Scatter Jackpotuniverse 6d pokermahjong quest genie seamen adventureevent neko throne challengewheels 09 roletkombo sempurna treasure island blackjackgila sehari bisafakta yang mencengangkan berikuthari ini pemain asaljuta dipakai untuk modalmodal saldo shopeepay kohpakai kesempatan emas inipecahan mengalir deras berkattanpa ada yang di rahasiakanpenjual bakso mengalami pengalamanlupakan soal strategi lamahanya memerluka 14 menittargetkan penyelesaian algoritma terbarujangan asal investasikan uangformasu lengkap antara rtpperbedaan signifikan yang palingpetinggi dorong percepatan regulasibanyak jadi perbincangan warganetjadi penentu gerbang kemenanganpembaruan menjadi daya tarikstrategy double till endturun gunung mencari tahubelajar dari pengalaman membuatBonanza Burst IslandBandito FrenzyDragon ThroneCMD Sportsbook ClashTiger Spin AdventureLucky Neko RoletMagical Black ScatterBaccarat Showdown RoyaleRoulette Moon SpinWild Bandito StrikeMahjong King UniverseSpaceman Crash VoyageBlackjack Super CardToto Jackpot Dreambaccarat untuk bulan oktoberbakal turun pada putaranbikin gebrakan kemenangan extrabisa menghancurkan perkalian besarbulan suram jadi ceriacek apakah akun andabukan hoax astronom temukanfajar perwira pria asaliming untuk raup untungjadi simbol tunjangan besarmencuri perhatian publik ketikaroullete sebagai mesin kemenangandari pemula menjadikaget saldo cashback sebesarrahasia sadis meraih jackpotrezeki nomplok dari providersaldo terakhir berhasil menangsempat kaget melihat pecahantapi saldo rekening nambahtrik ini lewat gameteknik dari game tembak ikangebrakan baru dari oxligadengan memanfaatkan ritme roomkemenangan di starlight princessmomen kemenangan yang mengubahoxliga menjadi pilihan para pemainpedagang putu bambu mendapatkanbikin baper dragon hatchares pedagang angkringan bermainbakso goreng gurih ala suhubanyak yang tidak tahubedah strategi mix parlay di oxligakuli proyek setelah berdiskusioxliga casino baccarat speed semakinBaccarat RoyaleRoullete FortuneLive KasinoFenomena Mahjong EffectMahjong Wins 3Sicbo LiveSABA EsportsLogin Winzo PokerEfek Tsumo Texas Elite MahjongMega Poker IndonesiaDragon Boom Thousands Baccarat Wheel BlazeAuto Roulette StrikeCode Cairo Totokeampuhan trik dari wahyuaryo anak skena yang kini suksesking heru setelah mendapatkanrudy seorang pakar gamesifu riski menghasilkan 545 jtseorang pecinta kucing hokiakhirnya angan bang icalhanya dengan modal minimalis bangoxliga cara tercepat mendapatkanpetrus berhasil meraih 106nelayan lombok wujudkan impianpenuh dengan kejutan menarikjalan keluar terbaru dari ekonomiarahan sederhana agar raihinilah metode yang berpeluangtanpa pakai orang dalamlakukan hal ini jika mauselalu jadi pusat perhatiankesuksesan anak mudarayakan festival megaways thundersemakin meningkat setiap saatikut partisipasi dalam pengembanganhampir 90 persen sudah merasakankorban terus bertambahtambahan penghasilan menarik perhatian